by goulton Fri 19 Mar 2021, 9:36 pm
Hello Rob
I'm glad to hear you have enrolled with the local RoSPA group. Of the two I, and many of my fellow riders, think they are the better of the two organisations as they are less presciptive in their outlook. What I mean by that is that, with IAM RoadSmart, if you don't carry out a manoeuvre exactly as described in their instruction book you will be penalised. RoSPA take a slightly more lenient approach but without any compromise to safety. RoSPA uses "Motorcycle Roadcraft" (sub-titled "police rider's handbook to better motorcycling") as the basis for training but if you don't follow it to the letter but the examiner thinks that what you do is perfectly safe and you can explain your thinking to the examiner it will be OK. That doesn't mean you can deviate widely or ignore the Highway Code but just be a bit flexible than the IAM.
If you detect a whiff of criticism in the above paragraph, you are correct. The British Police riders are some of the best and safest road riders in the world and they were responsible for writing the Roadcraft books. So why IAM RoadSmart goes off and writes their own manual (reinventing the wheel) I am at a loss to understand.
I joined our local motorcycle group, Essex Advanced Motorcycle Group, about 15 years ago. At the time they were an IAM group and I passed the IAM test. However, a year or two later they broke away from the IAM and became independent after disputes about our training methods. We were told that we should not conduct any further training after someone had passed their test, we took the attitude that learning to ride well is a life-long process and continue to help riders improve for as long as they wish. This means the group can offer both IAMRoadSmart and RoSPA training. I don't know the percentages but it will be at least 90% taking the RoSPA test.
You will gather that I am very much in favour of RoSPA over IAM RoadSmart. The RoSPA test has the advantage of being graded, bronze, silver and gold. I doubt you Derby group would say you are test ready until you are capable of passing at silver level. If you pass at this level you can consider yourself a very good rider indeed, if you pass at gold level you are the best of the best of civilian riders.
As another thought I would suggest you do not go out and buy a copy of Motorcycle Roadcraft as you will are likely to be given one by the Derby group in your welcome pack.
Chris